Member-only story

Metaethics and the Grounds of Moral Feeling: Unraveling the Foundations of Morality

Alan Turner

·11.9k Followers· Follow

Published in The Futility Of Philosophical Ethics: Metaethics And The Grounds Of Moral Feeling

5 min read · 4 weeks before

178 View Claps

18 Respond

Save

Listen

The realm of metaethics delves into the fundamental nature and basis of morality, examining the very foundations upon which our moral beliefs and judgments rest. In his groundbreaking work, "Metaethics and the Grounds of Moral Feeling," the renowned philosopher Simon Blackburn embarks on a captivating exploration of this enigmatic subject matter. This comprehensive article delves into the key themes and insights presented within the book, shedding light on the complexities and intricacies of metaethics.

The Enigma of Moral Motivation
At the heart of Blackburn's inquiry lies the perplexing question of moral motivation. Why do we experience certain actions as morally right or wrong? What drives us to act in accordance with moral principles, even when they conflict with our own self-interest? Blackburn postulates that morality cannot be adequately explained solely through rational reflection or empirical observation. Instead, he argues for the existence of a distinctively moral motivation, an intrinsic sense of right and wrong that guides our moral judgments and actions.

The Futility of Philosophical Ethics: Metaethics and the Grounds of Moral Feeling

by James Kirwan

4.8 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	2636 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Screen Reader	:	Supported
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Word Wise	:	Enabled
Print length	:	456 pages

Grounding Moral Feeling: Intuitionism and Naturalism
Blackburn examines two prominent theories that attempt to account for the grounds of moral feeling: intuitionism and naturalism. Intuitionists maintain that moral truths are self-evident and can be apprehended intuitively, without relying on external sources of authority or justification. Naturalists, on the other hand, contend that morality is grounded in natural facts or properties, such as human well-being or evolutionary fitness. Blackburn subjects both theories to rigorous scrutiny, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses, and ultimately argues for a hybrid approach that combines elements from both perspectives.

Metaethics and Everyday Morality
While metaethics delves into the abstract foundations of morality, Blackburn also explores its implications for everyday moral experience. He emphasizes the importance of understanding the subjective and emotional dimensions of moral judgment, arguing that metaethical insights can help us navigate the challenges and complexities of practical moral decision-making. Blackburn challenges simplistic notions of right and wrong, demonstrating the fluidity and context-dependency of moral values.

Moral Relativism Reconsidered
One of the most contentious issues within metaethics is moral relativism, the view that moral truths are relative to cultures or individuals. Blackburn engages in a nuanced discussion of relativism, acknowledging its seductive appeal while ultimately arguing against its foundational claims. He contends that morality possesses a degree of objectivity and universality, grounded in shared human experiences and values, even amidst cultural and contextual differences.

The Quest for Moral Knowledge
Blackburn concludes "Metaethics and the Grounds of Moral Feeling" by reflecting on the nature of moral knowledge and the challenges of establishing moral truths. He argues for a tempered epistemology of morality, acknowledging the limitations of human reason while emphasizing the possibility of genuine moral progress. Blackburn emphasizes the importance of ongoing dialogue, critical reflection, and humility in our pursuit of moral understanding.

"Metaethics and the Grounds of Moral Feeling" is an essential read for anyone seeking a deeper comprehension of the foundations of morality. Blackburn's profound insights and rigorous analysis provide a thought-provoking framework for understanding the complexities of metaethics. The book challenges simplistic views of right and wrong, highlighting the nuanced and often enigmatic nature of moral experience. By exploring the grounds of moral feeling, Blackburn illuminates the intricate interplay between reason, intuition, emotion, and social context in shaping our moral beliefs and actions. This seminal work invites readers to embark on an intellectual journey that will forever alter their perspective on the very nature of morality.

Alt Attributes for Descriptive Images:

Image 1: "The Enigma of Moral Motivation" - A depiction of a perplexed individual grappling with the complexities of moral judgment.
Image 2: "Grounding Moral Feeling" - A graphic representation of the interplay between intuitionism and naturalism, exploring the foundations of moral values.
Image 3: "Metaethics and Everyday Morality" - A photograph of people engaged in moral deliberation, highlighting the practical implications of metaethical insights.
Image 4: "Moral Relativism Reconsidered" - A cultural mosaic symbolizing the diversity of moral beliefs, illustrating the complexities of relativism.
Image 5: "The Quest for Moral Knowledge" - A group of scholars engaged in intellectual inquiry, representing the ongoing pursuit of moral understanding.

The Futility of Philosophical Ethics: Metaethics and the Grounds of Moral Feeling

by James Kirwan

4.8 out of 5